For people with sensitive skin, aftershaves offer a lot more than the soothing it gives the skin after shaving. Antiseptic components in several high-quality aftershaves help suppress ingrown hairs, razor bumps, and burn.

As someone with sensitive skin, typical aftershave always leaves my face feeling red and tired, but the products listed here led me to an aftershave that does not burn my skin or irritate it. The products here really are a game-changer if like me, you have sensitive skin.

It’s crucial to care for your facial skin after a shave. If you maintain your skin by keeping it moisturized and relaxed skin, that will secure the long-term care of it. You can use a splash on aftershave or a more moisturizing after shave cream whenever you’re done shaving.

The question is, what is the best aftershave for sensitive skin? I answer this question in the following skin-friendly and wallet-friendly choices below:

AHAVA Time to Energize After-Shave for Men – Best Natural Aftershave Balm

This after-shave is mineral-rich and moisturizes the skin after shaving. Its unique recipe guarantees it absorbs fast into the skin and aids in healing tiny cuts and nicks you may have gotten while shaving.

AHAVA Time to Energize After-Shave for Men, best aftershave for sensitive skin

Buy from Amazon

Antibacterial activity adds moisture to the skin, leaving it feeling smooth and rejuvenated. Ahava is a popular brand with a wide range of unique, powerful skincare products, which comprise a whole men’s line.

The moisturizing properties of AHAVA on my skin place this at the top of my choices as a natural balm. This is a brilliant aftershave to add to men’s luxury items due to its effectiveness as an aftershave balm for sensitive skin.

DIOR Sauvage Aftershave Balm – Best Moisturizing Aftershave Balm

The DIOR Sauvage Aftershave Balm is unavoidable in any discussion of the best aftershave for men.

Buy from Nordstrom

Whenever you’re stumped for a gift for that picky man on his birthday, or anniversary, and you want something different from a t-shirt, the DIOR Sauvage will make him feel delighted. The high-end aftershave balm contains an infusion of the best ingredients to complement your shaving routine.

The non-oily texture of this renowned moisturizing balm makes it the perfect choice if you have oily skin as this won’t make your skin look more shiny and oily. If you need to avoid that shine factor, this is your aftershave. It also calms and speeds up skin healing and is infused with enticing fragrance components that leave your skin smelling fresh.

Crabtree & Evelyn Aftershave Balm – Best Smelling Aftershave Balm

With an applewood and bergamot scent, this aftershave leaves you with a splendid, strong fragrance. It offers a calming, refreshing, and non-greasy sensation, making it ideal for your everyday routine. If you want an aftershave balm that soothes the skin and revitalizes your face, then this is for you.

The Crabtree & Evelyn aftershave soaks into the skin well. You may find the scent a little overbearing if you prefer a lighter and sweeter touch. This may clash with your cologne choice. It’s still the finest for that finishing touch once you’ve done your smooth shave.

For a silky smooth shave, go for this aftershave for sensitive skin. The balm not only moisturizes your skin but also leaves a strong but pleasant scent behind.

Taylor of Old Bond Street Aftershave Balm for Sensitive Skin – Best After Shave Balm for Work

Taylor of Old Bond Street is a well-known business that creates premium shaving and grooming products for men using high-quality ingredients. What makes it good for work is its lasting aroma. You’ll still be smelling the scent when you leave work and return home.

Buy from Amazon

The balm, which contains aloe, witch hazel, and allantoin, soothes and provides an alternative to lotions. If you seek to reduce shaving irritation and razor burn, this is your best choice. Since these balms contain no alcohol, the product gives your skin hydration and you feel refreshed after shaving.

Being allergen-free, It’s a fantastic aftershave for individuals with sensitive skin that want an alcohol-free aftershave.

Bulldog Sensitive Aftershave Balm – Most Affordable Aftershave Balm

This non-sticky aftershave balm qualifies as one of the best men’s aftershaves for sensitive skin. The Bulldog Sensitive Aftershave Balm is ideal for people with sensitive skin due to its ability to diminish nicks and redness while also soothing you to silky smooth skin.

Buy from Amazon

The balm is cool on the skin with natural and botanical components and is ideal for irritated skin. If you’re too sensitive to strong fragrances then this lighter weight choice will work best for you. It can feel a little greasy at first but does dry quickly. If you have very dry skin, you may find this doesn’t moisturize as well as expected.

Bulldog anti-inflammatory and hydrating after-shave balm offer two essential oils, cucumber, green tea extract, chamomile, and aloe vera. The balm reduces inflammation on your skin, and leaves it refreshed, nourished, and pure. It contains no artificial colors, parabens, synthetic scents, or animal-derived components.

Lather and Wood Aftershave Balm – Best Budget Aftershave Balm

There aren’t many aftershaves that pamper the skin leaving it smooth and refreshed with a distinct sandalwood fragrance at this price. This is great value for how well it smoothes and softens the skin.

Buy from Amazon

Lather and Wood’s non-drying aftershave balm soothes inflammation and stiffness and doesn’t leave any greasiness behind. So this is a suitable choice for both sensitive and oily skin. You won’t have any irritation from the balm after using a safety or straight razor.

The Lather & Wood contains a lot of natural ingredients for the budget price. Your skin will feel the effects of Aloe Vera which calms, and coconut oil which gives the balm antibacterial strengths. Extracts from coconut, aloe, and witch hazel for an astringent combine with vitamin E to make one of the best aftershave balms for sensitive skin for that perfect finish.

One of the best bargain pros of Lather & Wood balm is that you won’t need to apply a separate moisturizer as use of this aftershave balm applies an effective long-lasting softener.

Eliminate any irritation after shaving and moisturize for the day without prolonged oiliness by using Lather and Wood Balm.

Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm – Great Aftershave Balm for Sensitive Skin

Shaving is an artistic process, and the Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm is the last phase. This balm has a great recipe that moisturizes, easily absorbs, and calms your skin after shaving.

Buy from Nordstrom

If you need a high-quality aftershave balm with no fragrance at an affordable price, this is your aftershave choice. This offers you the scent of pure oils and a great softener that best suits dry skin. For that reason, it’s not suitable for oily skin.

With this alcohol-free aftershave, you’re guaranteed a hydrated and instant soothing effect for your dry skin with no redness or irritation. It’s made with grapeseed and shea butter to help your skin stay healthy, as well as antiseptic to keep germs at bay. The shea butter places fatty acids on your skin which not only moisturizes but also protects your shaven face from environmental damage.

Are you a regular shaver with dry skin? This is a fantastic choice.

Weleda Men’s Aftershave Balm – Great Aftershave for Instant Relief

Weleda Aftershave Balm can help you avoid parabens and phthalates so if seeking a paraben-free alternative, this is the aftershave for you. Consumers tend to go for phthalate-free products due to the health concerns from them.

Buy from Amazon

This balm gives immediate relief from irritation and brings an infusion of necessary moisture. The balm contains aloe vera and jojoba oil to protect your face from dryness. It soothes the skin gently after your dry or wet shave. Your skin feels supple after one application and you pick up a refreshing but not overpowering fragrance. It offers all the calming effects, leaving no greasiness or sticky residue behind.

The big seller points include lots of value for your bucks and protection qualities. Only small amounts bring you long-lasting moisturizing for the day. So the 100ml will last a while during your daily smooth finishes. The ingredients include organic chamomile which prevents any razor burn. So you rushed your shave and damaged the skin. Weleda quickly soothes the pain and damage with its instant relief promise.

Each of Weleda’s formulations reflects the company’s commitment to simplicity and ease of use. There’s no-nonsense here; just solid, dependable ingredients that make your skin feel and look beautiful.

Nuxe Men Multi-purpose Aftershave Balm – Most Efficient Aftershave Balm

With NUXE’s multi-purpose balm, you’ll find the right method to complete your shave. This is one of the best aftershaves for sensitive skin available since it is hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic.

Buy from Amazon

Sandalwood and Phellodendron extracts combine to rebuild the hydrolipid layer, which helps in calming and protecting the skin. Oak and hornbeam extracts help to restore the skin’s barrier function, while baobab leaves provide long-lasting moisturization.

This leads us to the aracuria extract, which invigorates specific areas. Use of this balm replenishes energy and vigor to skin that the razor or environmental causes have paled. Gymnema Sylvestre, a tropical woody plant, stops shaven hairs from regrowing right away.

With only one application of this amazing balm, you can soothe your skin and add some variety to your regimen.

Aftershaves for Sensitive Skin – What Does An Aftershave Do?

There are three major functions of aftershaves:

1. Infection-Prevention Antiseptic

Above all, aftershaves work as an antiseptic, preventing infections from shaving cuts or nicks. The ingredients in most aftershaves that serve as disinfectants are alcohol which gives the sting when you apply it- stearate citrate, or witch hazel.

2. Relieve Irritation and Soothe Skin

The skin soothes from the use of aftershave. The most frequent purpose is reducing irritation using astringents- a skin cleanser that tightens the pores to prevent bleeding. Some people take it a step further by using menthol to numb the skin. The balms soothe irritation by hydrating dry skin in the same way as a face lotion would.

3. Gives You a Delightful Smell

Aftershaves are the first point of pleasant scents for most men. Although the nice scent may not be as long-lasting as a proper cologne, It’s still a pleasant complement to your shaving routine. You can layer your aftershave with a cologne if your aftershave goes off too easily during the day.

How to Pick the Best Aftershave for Sensitive Skin Types

Consider them as a supplement to your skincare routine and choose one that matches your skin tone. Aftershaves contain the fragrance, an astringent, a moisturizer, and an antiseptic.

Why do you need an aftershave? There are reasons you will benefit from its usage when at home or traveling with your toiletry bag. In the same way that plowing a field disrupts the surface, when you shave, a layer of skin peels away. The resulting open pores may allow microbes to dig deep into your skin.

Pay special attention to the ingredients, as you need to choose a nontoxic brand. Some aftershaves might cause a stinging feeling, so check if the label states it’s odorless and alcohol-free, and soothes skin instead like the Balm choices I listed above.

The alcohol in many aftershaves causes a stinging pain. It kills bacteria and helps guard against the buildup of skin toxins, which is why people with less sensitive skin choose aftershaves with alcohol. With sensitive skin, your choices for non-toxic products include aftershave balm, and the use of witch hazel or shea butter.

People with sensitive skin should avoid products that include synthetic perfumes. This is true of all skincare products, but notably, aftershaves, which are applied on shaven skin when it is raw and irritable. Avoid the use of alum blocks to stop any bleeding, as these will draw too much moisture from your skin.

The best aftershaves for sensitive skin will often avoid the non-essentials and instead employ high-quality components to soothe and protect the skin after a shave.

Oily Skin

Splashes are the best option for oily skin. A splash aftershave is less likely to clog your pores, and the astringent properties can help if you have acne. However, if the splashes bother your skin, switch to an oil-free aftershave gel. Ensure that it’s not too heavy to clog your pores.

Dry Skin

Cold weather, a dry environment, or the natural aging process can all cause dry skin. In all situations, though, don’t go for splashes, which may dry out your skin even more. Rather, choose more moisturizing solutions like aftershave balms and lotions. Men with dry or sensitive skin should choose alcohol-free aftershave balms. They function like a lotion, hydrating and replenishing important oils to the skin.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the difference between aftershave and aftershave Balm?

Because we aren’t working with strict definitions, there isn’t a definite answer. However, aftershaves are available in liquid form, whilst aftershave balms are in a lotion form. Avoid alcohol-based compounds which might create a mild burning feeling by choosing one of the recommended balms. Rather than relying on the label, consider what you want (or don’t want) in aftershave and purchase based on those factors.

Is the “sensitive skin” tag just a marketing ploy?

As you’ve read here, there are reasons some aftershaves will cause pain when applied. There are chemicals that will irritate sensitive skin more than other types, alcohol being the top cause. Though other conditions can irritate the skin, such as eczema and careless shaving techniques. You need an aftershave balm that provides a gentle application for sensitive, low-tolerance skin. So many people can experience sensitive skin issues at least once in life, such as redness, allergic reactions, and burning. Find out which product works best for you.

Should I just choose products labeled as “hypoallergenic”?

All hypoallergenic means is that the product will cause fewer allergic reactions than products not labeled thus. Skin allergies are common and allergic directions are a daily issue for many people. But, when you see the term “Hypoallergenic”, know that it is a marketing term and not a scientific-based term.

The only guarantee you have at finding an aftershave that won’t hurt your sensitive skin is to follow my recommendations and preventive measures here in this article. While I listed natural ingredients along with the balms, do remember some natural ingredients will irritate the skin such as lemon, orange, and avoid menthol.

It’s the ingredients you need to check and not marketing labels.

Best of Aftershave Balms for Sensitive Skin Types Summarized

For all sensitive skin types, there is a perfect choice for you here. If you have dry skin, add lasting moisture with the AHAVA Time to Energize After-Shave or Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm. To gain the best value for money on your aftershave for a product that suits all skin types, choose the moisturizing yet non-greasy Weleda Men’s Aftershave Balm 100ml bottle.

Whether you have very dry or oily skin, there is a brand of aftershave ready to satisfy your needs. Try out the recommended aftershave here for sensitive skin and complete that smooth finish.

[icon name=”flag” prefix=”fas”] Now that your skin is covered, what about your signature scent? Check out our cologne guides to find yours:

What’s Changed?

We updated this guide in January 2024 to reflect the most recent pricing.

The Best Aftershave for Sensitive Skin: Preventing The Burn